Our Signature Christmas Cookie Assortments

Beautifully styled on a festive platter. Just unwrap, serve, and delight your guests.

Let’s make the season a little sweeter, together.

Below, you’ll find information about our Christmas cookie assortments, gift boxes, and even ready-to-decorate cutout cookies. If you have any questions as you make your selections, check out our FAQs at the bottom of the page! Can’t find the details you’re looking for? Give us a call (919.283.1009) or send us a note.

Each assortment is delivered ready to serve, beautifully arranged on a festive platter.

Just unwrap and set out — no time-consuming rearranging required!

When you order an assortment, you’ll have the option to select the style of your tray.

We collect trays from estate sales, vintage shops, and the like to be sure that your assortment can be beautifully styled, unique, and ready to set out for your guests the moment we hand it to you! You’ll choose from three categories:

  • Colorful Vintage

  • Colorful Modern

  • Classic Glass

Below are some examples to help you make your selection.

(Please note that these are for illustrative purposes only; these particular trays may not be available at the time of your order.)

Curious about the cookies we’re baking this season?

An in-progress list of cookies with descriptions can be found here.

Select your Christmas Cookies

We’ll provide the Christmas magic — you just tell us how many elves you want to serve!


Premium Assortment $159

$159

Serves up to 35 guests

Our largest and most indulgent tray, brimming with 120 hand-selected gourmet cookies in a variety of festive flavors — including premium desserts you won’t find on any of our other trays.

The Premium Assortment is designed to impress, making it the ideal choice for holiday parties, family gatherings, or corporate events. With a delicious mix of gourmet cookies, this tray is guaranteed to delight your guests.

Each assortment is delivered ready to serve, beautifully arranged on a festive platter. Just unwrap and set out — no time-consuming rearranging required!

Includes:

  • 12 dz gourmet grazing-size cookies, serving 25-35 guests

  • 20-30 varieties of cookies included (assortments vary)

  • Beautifully arranged on a festive tray

  • For orders over $100, delivery is included within 10 miles of downtown Boone, NC (28607) or downtown Cary, NC (27511). Pickup is also available in Boone and Cary. (Extended delivery is available for a $20-$35 fee, which covers our expenses delivering to you! See checkout for details.)

Cookie varieties and arrangements vary — each assortment is thoughtfully curated and no two assortments are exactly alike! Photos are provided as examples only.

Curious about what cookies will be on your tray? See the possibilities here.

Premium Christmas Cookie Assortment (serves up to 35 guests)
$159.00

Our largest and most indulgent tray, brimming with 120 hand-selected gourmet cookies in a variety of festive flavors — including premium desserts you won’t find on any of our other trays.

The Premium Assortment is designed to impress, making it the ideal choice for holiday parties, family gatherings, or corporate events. With a delicious mix of gourmet cookies, this tray is guaranteed to delight your guests.

Each assortment is delivered ready to serve , beautifully arranged on a festive platter. Just unwrap and set out — no time-consuming rearranging required!

Includes:

  • 12 dz gourmet grazing-size cookies, serving 25-35 guests

  • 20-30 varieties of cookies included (assortments vary)

  • Beautifully arranged on a festive tray

  • For orders over $100, delivery is included within 10 miles of downtown Boone, NC (28607) or downtown Cary, NC (27511). Pickup is also available in Boone and Cary. (Extended delivery is available for a $20-$35 fee, which covers our expenses delivering to you! See checkout for details)

Standard Assortment

$109

Serves up to 20 guests

Perfect for smaller get-togethers or as a host gift. The Standard Assortment offers a delightful mix of festive classics and new favorites that will bring cheer to any holiday gathering.

Each assortment is delivered ready to serve, beautifully arranged on a festive platter. Just unwrap and set out — no time-consuming rearranging required!

Includes:

  • 6 dz gourmet bite-sized cookies, serving 15-20 guests

  • 12-20 varieties included (assortments vary)

  • Beautifully arranged on a festive tray

  • For orders over $100, delivery is included within 10 miles of downtown Boone, NC (28607) or downtown Cary, NC (27511). Pickup is also available in Boone and Cary. (Extended delivery is available for a $20-$35 fee, which covers our expenses delivering to you! See checkout for details.)

Cookie varieties and arrangements vary — each assortment is thoughtfully curated and no two assortments are exactly alike! Photos are provided as examples only.

Curious about what cookies will be on your tray? See the possibilities here.

Standard Christmas Cookie Assortment (serves up to 20 guests)
$109.00

Perfect for smaller get-togethers or as a host gift. The Standard Assortment offers a delightful mix of festive classics and new favorites that will bring cheer to any holiday gathering.

Each assortment is delivered ready to serve , beautifully arranged on a festive platter. Just unwrap and set out — no time-consuming rearranging required!

Includes:

  • 6 dz gourmet bite-sized cookies, serving 15-20 guests

  • 12-20 varieties included (assortments vary)

  • Beautifully arranged on a festive tray

  • For orders over $100, delivery is included within 10 miles of downtown Boone, NC (28607) or downtown Cary, NC (27511). Pickup is also available in Boone and Cary. (Extended delivery is available for a $20-$35 fee, which covers our expenses delivering to you! See checkout for details)

Starter Assortment

$49

Serves up to 8 guests

A bit of sweetness for more intimate and cozy holiday gatherings.

Each assortment is delivered ready to serve, beautifully arranged on a festive platter. Just unwrap and set out — no time-consuming rearranging required!

Includes:

  • 2 dz gourmet bite-sized cookies, serving 15-20 guests

  • Approximately 6 varieties included

  • Featuring classics like peppermint rounds, mini cutouts, brown-butter blondies, gingerbread latte cookies, chocolate shortbreads, buttery confetti cookies, or other goodies (assortments vary)

  • Beautifully arranged, ready to serve on a festive tray

  • For orders over $100, delivery is included within 10 miles of downtown Boone, NC (28607) or downtown Cary, NC (27511). Pickup is also available in Boone and Cary. (Extended delivery is available for a $20-$35 fee, which covers our expenses delivering to you! See checkout for details.)

Cookie varieties and arrangements vary — each assortment is thoughtfully curated and no two assortments are exactly alike! Photos are provided as examples only.

Curious about what cookies will be on your tray? See the possibilities here.

Starter Christmas Cookie Assortment (serves up to 8 guests)
$49.00

A bit of sweetness for more intimate and cozy holiday gatherings.

Each assortment is delivered ready to serve , beautifully arranged on a festive platter. Just unwrap and set out — no time-consuming rearranging required!

Includes:

  • 2 dz gourmet bite-sized cookies, serving 15-20 guests

  • Approximately 6 varieties included

  • Featuring classics like peppermint rounds, mini cutouts, brown-butter blondies, gingerbread latte cookies, chocolate shortbreads, buttery confetti cookies, or other goodies (assortments vary)

  • Beautifully arranged, ready to serve on a festive tray

  • For orders over $100, delivery is included within 10 miles of downtown Boone, NC (28607) or downtown Cary, NC (27511). Pickup is also available in Boone and Cary. (Extended delivery is available for a $20-$35 fee, which covers our expenses delivering to you! See checkout for details.)

Personal Gift Boxes

Available as single purchase ($29) or set of 4 boxes ($99)

Ordering for a team of 25 or more? Send us a note for custom bulk pricing.

1 dz beautifully assorted cookies heat-sealed for freshness and nestled inside a festive gift box. Perfect for gifting to teachers, neighbors, clergy, team members, family helpers, or anyone who deserves a sweet holiday treat. (Don’t we all?)

Includes:

  • 1 dz gourmet bite-sized cookies

  • 4-6 varieties included (assortments vary)

  • Heat-sealed for freshness and beautifully packaged inside a festive gift box

  • For orders over $100, delivery is included within 10 miles of downtown Boone, NC (28607) or downtown Cary, NC (27511). Pickup is also available in Boone and Cary. (Extended delivery is available for a $20-$35 fee, which covers our expenses delivering to you! See checkout for details.)

Personal Gift Box - Available as single purchase ($29) or set of 4 boxes ($99)
from $29.00

1 dz beautifully assorted cookies heat-sealed for freshness and nestled inside a festive gift box. Perfect for gifting to teachers, neighbors, clergy, team members, family helpers, or anyone who deserves a sweet holiday treat.

Includes:

  • 1 dz gourmet bite-sized cookies

  • 4-6 varieties included (assortments vary)

  • Heat-sealed for freshness and beautifully packaged inside a festive gift box

  • For orders over $100, delivery is included within 10 miles of downtown Boone, NC (28607) or downtown Cary, NC (27511). Pickup is also available in Boone and Cary. (Extended delivery is available for a $20-$35 fee, which covers our expenses delivering to you! See checkout for details)

Ready-to-Decorate Cutout Sugar Cookies

Decorate cutout cookies this year without the hassle and mess of mixing, rolling, cutting, and baking. These delicious sugar cut-outs are ready for your family to make their own!

Includes:

  • 1 dz cutouts in Christmas shapes (stars, trees, snowmen, etc.), approximately inches each

  • For orders over $100, delivery is included within 10 miles of downtown Boone, NC (28607) or downtown Cary, NC (27511). Pickup is also available in Boone and Cary. (Extended delivery is available for a $20-$35 fee, which covers our expenses delivering to you! See checkout for details.)

Ready-to-Decorate Cutout Sugar Cookies
$19.00

Decorate cutout cookies this year without the hassle and mess of mixing, rolling, cutting, and baking. These delicious sugar cut-outs are ready for your family to make their own!

Includes:

  • 1 dz cutouts in Christmas shapes (stars, trees, snowmen, etc.), approximately inches each

  • For orders over $100, delivery is included within 10 miles of downtown Boone, NC (28607) or downtown Cary, NC (27511). Pickup is also available in Boone and Cary. (Extended delivery is available for a $20-$35 fee, which covers our expenses delivering to you! See checkout for details.)

$19/dz

Specialty Cookies by the Dozen

If you or a loved one has a favorite cookie, we know you might want a full dozen of them! Many of our specialty cookies are available by the dozen. To find your favorite and to see pricing, check the dropdown menu below!

Cookie descriptions can be found here.

Please note that cookies by the dozen are delivered in boxes, not on decorative trays. If you are also purchasing a cookie assortment and would like your dozen to be added to your tray, please mention it in your message.

For orders over $100, delivery is included within 10 miles of downtown Boone, NC (28607) or downtown Cary, NC (27511). Pickup is also available in Boone and Cary. (Extended delivery is available for a $20-$35 fee, which covers our expenses delivering to you! See checkout for details.)

Cookies by the dozen (choose your cookie)
from $16.00

For varieties and pricing, see the dropdown menu below!

Questions about cookies? Descriptions can be found here.

Please note that cookies by the dozen are delivered in boxes, not on decorative trays. If you are also purchasing a cookie assortment and would like your dozen to be added to your tray, please note it in your message.

For orders over $100, delivery is included within 10 miles of downtown Boone, NC (28607) or downtown Cary, NC (27511). Pickup is also available in Boone and Cary. (Extended delivery is available for a $20-$35 fee, which covers our expenses delivering to you! See checkout for details.)

$16 - $30 / dozen, depending on variety

Christmas Cookie FAQs