What cookies will be included?

Assortments vary based on availability at the time of delivery. No two assortments are the same!

If there is a cookie you’re particularly interested in, most varieties can also be ordered by the dozen during the Christmas season (Nov-Dec). Cookies by the dozen range from $15/dz to $32/dz.

For Christmas 2026, your holiday cookie tray may include:

Chocolately Cookies

Fudgy Brownie Bites

We believe if you’re going to eat a brownie, it should be an excellent brownie. And these are excellent brownies. Classic, melt-in-your-mouth, and oh-so-fudgy.

Tahini Chocolate Chip Cookies

A subtle twist on an old favorite, the addition of tahini gives these cookies a dimension of warmth that makes a classic even better than before.

Nostalgic Chocolate Chip Cookie Bars

Soft bars dotted with semi-sweet chips. Like eating a cookie cake — but better.

Lace Sandwich Cookies (GF)

Caramelly and rich with brown butter, these delicate cookies are sandwiched with chocolate to give them body and dimension.

Fruity Cookies

Banana Puddin’ Cookies

Soft and sweet, stuffed with made-from-scratch vanilla wafers and vanilla chips.

Cherry Almond Dreams

Cathlyn’s favorite from childhood, these are soft and crumbly shortbreads topped with a sweet, red maraschino cherry.

Raspberry Streusel Bars

A sweet and buttery oat crumble complements the mild tartness of raspberry jam.

Nutty Cookies

Pistachio Drop Cookies

These cookies are flavored with real pistachios and almond extract (no artificial flavors here!). Crumbly and lightly sweet, they’ll have your guests reaching for more.

Peanut Brittle

A crunchy and sweet nostalgic classic.

Nut Brittle

Trade out the traditional peanuts for a mix of nuts. Makes it peanut-free and gives it a surprising new take!

Pecan Sandies

A lightly sweet and nutty classic.

Peanut Butter Balls

Creamy, buttery, sweet peanut butter — covered in chocolate.

Peanut Butter Blossoms

A peanut butter cookie base topped with a chocolate kiss.

Classic Peanut Butter Cookies

With the fork marks and all.

Coconut Cookies

Coconut Almond Candies

These are almost too good. Shredded coconut, almonds, and sweetened condensed milk come together for a decadent treat.

Dipped Chocolate Coconut Cookies

A light, crispy coconut cookie dipped in chocolate and topped with toasted coconut.

Minty Cookies

Creme de Menthe Snowballs

Soft and buttery, with just a touch of sweet mint.

Peppermint Rounds

Brightly colored and visually appealing, these aren’t your typical “spicy” mint cookies. The peppermint itself is light, sweet, and crowd pleasing.

Minty Oreo Cookies (V)

Like mint oreo ice cream, in cookie form.

Botanicals & Aromatics

Rose Cardamom Shortbreads

Lightly sweet and mildly aromatic, these shortbreads are beautifully dotted with crushed rose leaves.

Matcha Crinkles

Matcha fans love these bright green cookies with their shiny, crackly tops!

Biscochitos

The name might remind you of “biscotti” or “Biscoff,” but biscochitos are neither! These Mexican favorites are oh-so-crumbly, lightly sweet, and taste like Christmas.

Ginger Latte Cookies (V)

A delightful combination of light flavors means these ginger latte cookies are beautifully spiced, with a hint of coffee flavor adding dimension and contrast.

Earl Grey and Rose Cookies

A little floral and a little peppery, with just the right touch of sweetness.

Neutral Sweet Cookies

Festive Christmas Confetti Cookies

A crunchy, buttery cookie decorated with red and green sprinkles.

Brown Butter Blondies

A simple classic with a deep caramel-toffee flavor.

S’mores Sprinkle Bars

Toffee-coated graham crackers are topped with gooey marshmallows and Christmas sprinkles.

Salted Honey Cookies

Sweet and salty — the perfect combination.

Premium Cookies

Premium cookies appear only within the Premium Assortments.

Festive Macarons

Light and colorful meringue shells with a layer of buttercream or jam inside.

Venetians

Three layers of colorful sponge cake layered with apricot and rasperry jams, topped with a delicate layer of chocolate.

Mini Peanut Butter Temptations

A peanut butter cookie shell filled with creamy Buckeye filling and topped with chocolate and peanuts.

Mini Cinnamon Apple Pie Temptations

A cinnamon cookie base, filled with warmly spiced homemade apple pie filling, and topped with oat streusel.

Ready to order?